In this article, two issues are discussed that suggest that these conclusions are. Methodological issues in the metaanalysis of quasiexperiments. An introduction to methodological issues when including. Methodological paper methodological issues in the analysis of. The paper concludes with a discussion of the use and interpretation of the technique as well as questions. A methodological and empirical critique of psychotherapy. Mostly because of methodological problems, almost 3u4 of an. However, poor reporting of crossover trials will often impede attempts to perform a metaanalysis using the available methods. In this note, we discuss several issues that arise from the analysis of the. To give an uptodate assessment of the association of alcohol with female breast cancer, addressing methodological issues and shortfalls in previous overviews. Its three prior editions have long served as onestop shopping resources for advanced undergraduates, graduate students, and faculty members hoping to consult the best articles bearing on methodological issues and advances in clinical. Metaanalysis for comparative environmental case studies. Issues addressed metaanalysis cannot transcend the limitations of the data upon which it is based.
Study quality assessed by objective criteria including degree of. Methodological issues in a metaanalysis original manuscript. Metaanalysis oxford academic journals oxford university press. There are over 165 studies that have focused on thimerosal, an organicmercury hg based compound, used as a preservative in many childhood vaccines, and found it to be harmful.
Meta analysis for comparative environmental case studies. Metaanalysis of studies any language providing original data on incidence of first primary breast cancer and alcohol. Metaanalysis, a set of statistical techniques for synthesizing the results of. The role of facial response in the experience of emotion. Of these, 16 were conducted to specifically examine the effects of thimerosal on human infants or children with reported. May 14, 2012 in this metaanalysis, we give a comprehensive overview of the effects of meditation on psychological variables that can be extracted from empirical studies, concentrating on the effects of meditation on nonclinical groups of adult meditators. Shapiro and shapiro 1982, 1983 noted that unconstrained randomization was used in 57% of the client groups. Key j1, hodgson s, omar rz, jensen tk, thompson sg, boobis ar, davies ds, elliott p. Considering the methodological limitations in the evidence. The results suggest that the effect sizes are small. In many instances, the results of these multiple small studies of an issue are diverse.
Your criteria will depend on what youre studying and any specific methodological issues in the field. Jun 25, 2010 this letter, however, focuses on concerns about methodological issues in the meta. A random effects metaanalysis was then conducted, with subgroup moderator analysis and metaregression. The research design and hypotheses of primary studies need to be very similar, if not identical cooper 1998. Schmidt md, phd, mba department of pathology, university of utah school of medicine and arup laboratories, salt lake city, utah. Oct 28, 2010 if possible the results are statistically combined into a metaanalysis in which the data are weighted and pooled to produce an estimate of effect. Methodological challenges associated with o metaanalyses. To read the fulltext of this research, you can request a copy directly from the authors. Methodological issues in inferences from metaanalysis about the effects of child sexual abuse.
Indicate that the work is a form of metaanalysis e. Alan kazdins edited compilation of readings, methodological issues and strategies in clinical research miscr, is a classic, and for good reason. Pdf methodological issues and advances in biological. The last decade seems to have resolved many of the statistical issues they listed but, for emerging practical problems in biological metaanalysis, see lajeunesse 2010. Metaanalysis in biological sciences, especially in ecology and evolution which we refer to as biological metaanalysis faces somewhat different methodological problems from its counterparts in medical and social sciences, where metaanalytic. In world situations such as poverty, war, oppression, ethnic conflict, and identity issues cannot be understood without creationland. Qualitative metaanalysis article reporting standards information recommended for inclusion in manuscripts reporting qualitative metaanalyses title and title page title indicate the key issues topic under consideration. Since metaanalysis has been introduced to the field of ecology and evolution, researchers have identified many methodological problems that. Methodological issues in a metaanalysis request pdf. Methodological challenges associated with o metaanalyses in.
Conceptual and methodological issues emil pull, guy baeten, carina listerborn and maria persdotter it is in the act of displacement that housing injustice finds its prime expression. Meta analysis is a quantitative technique that uses specific measures e. A bluffers guide to metaanalysis1 discovering statistics. Methodological issues and strategies in clinical research on. Methodological issues and strategies in clinical research.
Methodological issues and evidence of malfeasance in research. Metaanalysis of the impact of microcredit on women s control. Statistical heterogeneity is the term given to differences in the effects of interventions and comes about because of clinical andor methodological differences between studies ie it is a consequence of clinical andor methodological heterogeneity. Since meta analysis has been introduced to the field of ecology and evolution, researchers have identified many methodological problems that. Methodological issues in inferences from metaanalysis. Effect of metformin on clinical, metabolic and endocrine outcomes in women with polycystic ovary syndrome. There is no doubt that metaanalysis has been one of the most important methodological developments in many fields of research including medical, social and biological sciences egger et al. Methodological issues and advances in biological meta. Methods for selecting relevant and appropriate quasiexperimental studies for inclusion in research synthesis using the threatstovalidity approach are presented. In fact, in a recent meta analysis of comparative psychotherapy outcome research that focused on some of the best studies in this area, d.
Smith, glass and millers 1980 optimistic appraisal of the outcome field is reassessed in view of both the methodological problems with metaanalysis and a reanalysis of two recent outcome metaanalyses. In this metaanalysis, we give a comprehensive overview of the effects of meditation on psychological variables that can be extracted from empirical studies, concentrating on the effects of meditation on nonclinical groups of adult meditators. Methodological issues in a metaanalysis reply request pdf. Metaanalysis of studies of alcohol and breast cancer with consideration of the methodological issues. Metaanalysis of studies of alcohol and breast cancer with. This article addresses common methodological problems that have plagued assessment research on ethnic minorities. Statistical heterogeneity is the term given to differences in the effects of interventions and comes about because of clinical andor methodological differences between studies ie it is a consequence of clinical andor methodological. The authors tried to evaluate the effect of oral contraceptive duration on hypertension risk, as well as assess the possible dose. New directions for program evaluation, n24 p524 dec 1984. Association between duration of oral contraceptive use and. Methodological challenges associated with metaanalyses in. Methodological problems in the use of indirect comparisons.
The impact of methodological moderators on prevalence rates of workplace bullying. She has authored several metaanalyses as well as articles on methodological issues in the area, and made numerous presentations on the topic. Robust epidemiological and economics methodological tools are available to measure inequalities in health, but, there are also numerous methodological issues that the study of health inequalities presents. Request pdf on jul 1, 2010, kristian thorlund and others published methodological issues in a metaanalysis reply find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate. The ability to perform metaanalysis is limited because few studies use the same operational definitions for variables and rarely provide enough descriptive statistics. It is our belief that conducting valid assessment research with ethnic minority groups is particularly problematic because of methodological, conceptual, and practical difficulties that arise in such research. Original text and translationsas indicated in the previous section, one of the methodological problems often found in comparative religious engagements is the presence of faulty or biased translations. Faculty of economics, university of catania, corso. Request pdf on jul 1, 2010, pierre cremieux published methodological issues in a metaanalysis find, read and cite all the research you need on researchgate.
Pdf theoretical and methodological issues daniel millet. Chronic periodontitis and the risk of erectile dysfunction. Principles and tools for evaluating commu scand j public health 2001. To the editor i read the study conducted by liu et al 1 that was published in the journal of clinical hypertension. The validity of the random effects model used in the article is dependent on a large number of individual studies, each with sufficiently large samples. Prevalence of psychotic disorders and its association with. However, poor reporting of crossover trials will often impede attempts to perform a meta analysis using the available methods. Meta analysis is a quantitative, formal, epidemiological study design used to. It is, therefore, characterized by a high level of transversality, both horizontally identification, selection and analysis of the case studies under consideration and vertically identification and description of the problem to be studied, definition of the. We provide an assessment of methodological quality and present the findings of a metaanalysis. We evaluated the methodological issues of these srmas. Methodological issues and advances in biological metaanalysis. In a more statistical sense, meta analysis combines common effectsize statistics e.
Pdf methodological issues and advances in biological meta. In the era of evidencebased medicine, credible evidence is the foundation upon which trustworthy decisions are built. Methodological standards for metaanalyses and qualitative. It can but hold a mirror to the scientific community, summarizing the conclusions and the quality of the available evidence concerning the substantive questions at issue. Methodological issues in a metaanalysis curr med res opin. To offset this problem, we shall use throughout our study translations into english of the visuddhimagga, and castillo considered authoritative. Out of seven eligible studies, only twelve comparisons can be made.
50 252 74 535 1336 688 385 1286 1087 362 1026 896 413 547 345 618 1107 871 323 1402 1391 186 1396 1342 346 1144 564